Q & A on James Baldwin


M402 --FIVE AFRICAN AMERICAN WRITERS

For discussion on 8 October 2018

Q & A on James Baldwin



Q1:  Was Baldwin's intent  of the threshing floor scenario to be considered more of a religious experience or a spiritual one or both?



Religion and spirituality are not mutually exclusive; they are interrelated and can't be threshed one from the other as easily as grain can be threshed from chaff.  It is reasonable to believe that Baldwin intended for readers of Go Tell It on the Mountain  to consider that John Grimes'  experiences on the floor in the temple were simultaneously religious and spiritual.  The saints are witnessing John's demonstration of a religious experience in a form that is consonant with their beliefs.  John is having a profoundly spiritual experience, his soul or spirit being acted upon by "the lash, the fire, and the depthless water."



Although the primary focus is on John's experience, the omniscient narrator compels us to deal with  the threshing that occurs as Florence and Gabriel engage in sibling recrimination which is marked by accusation rather than mercy and forgiveness.  Thus, Baldwin uses the final segment of the novel to confirm (1)  that John is coming through on his spiritual journey toward salvation and (2) that Florence and Gabriel may never reach consensus in terms of their unrelenting beliefs about religion.  For readers, the threshing does not have closure.



Q2:  Though having a major impact on Baldwin's life, would his attitude toward organized religion change in his later writings depicting it more as a means of social control?



Always a preacher or maker of sermons, in his later writings Baldwin does acknowledge that organized religion had been used in history as a means of social control.  Nevertheless, Baldwin was keenly aware that organized religion can be transformed into a tool for resisting oppression even if it is not the very best instrument for achieving liberation or freedom.  He seemed to be convinced that religion was to be used to disturb the peace, to avoid total victimization or becoming complacent about things as they are.

In an interview with Kalamu ya Salaam[The Black Collegian, 10 (1979)], Baldwin said "The essential religion of Black people comes out of something which is not Europe.  When black people talk about true religion, they're 'speaking in tongues' practically.  It would not be understood in Rome."  Baldwin did not lock himself in a box when it came to thinking about the roles of religion in everyday life.



There is no definitive answer to this question.   Major writers do not allow us to delude ourselves with a single answer to any question.  In the case of James Baldwin, we need to read as much of his truth-telling nonfiction as we can ------all the writing  in The Price of the Ticket: Collected Nonfiction 1948-1985 (New York: St. Martin's/Marek, 1985) and The Cross of Redemption: Uncollected Writings, ed. Randall Kenan ( New York: Pantheon Books, 2010).



Jerry W. Ward, Jr.            October 5, 2018

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

CLA paper

CLA,   April 6, 2018 Jerry W. Ward, Jr. PHBW:   Negotiating the Ideas of Seven Writers [1]                 Founded in 1983 by Dr. Maryemma Graham, "The Afro-American Novel Project" (AANP) had the initial goal of identifying all published novels written by African Americans from the nineteenth century to the late twentieth century.   AANP became The Project on the History of Black Writing (PHBW) in 1990 to reflect an enlarged vision and a more ambitious aim.   PHBW want to make a substantial contribution to what we then spoke of as our "Profession" by organizing bibliographic information and databases, sponsoring institutes and seminars, and by encouraging our colleagues to have rigorous engagements with all genres of black (African American) "writing" within   frames   of historical inquiry.                              The Project's   working frame was an   adaptation of the paradigm of unity in African American Studies , f
Read more

reading notes for September 23, 2019

Reading Notes for September 23, 2019 Eighteen years after the tragedy of 9/11 as I re-read Amiri Baraka's "Somebody Blew Up America" (2001), two meanderings occur: 1) a chance temptation to ask what the term "pro-Semitic" can mean in the contexts of (a) Israeli and world politics and (b) to what extent the amount of foreign aid the USA donates to Israel truly matters, and 2) a more focused temptation to ask if Morrison's Playing in the Dark sheds light on the motives that govern projects devoted to discussions of slavery beginning with 1619. I suspect those projects are at once very literary and very political. Such speculations arose during a September 12 conversation with one of my former UNCF/Mellon mentees whose research on redemption now teaches me, the former mentor, a few things about the urgency of scholarship in the twenty-first century.   The journey forth happens in the cognitive territory of "universal enslavement,"
Read more

Tell Them We Are Rising

TELL THEM WE ARE RISING TAKE ONE/ 16 February 2018                                                                                       Scene: Ash é Power House, 1731 Baronne Street, New Orleans, LA Act:   PBS/Indie Lens Film Screening: "Tell Them We Are Rising: The Story of Black Colleges and Universities" Purpose:   To view a short version of Stanley Nelson's most recent documentary, a visual narrative of many narratives, designed "to tell the dynamic story of Americans who refused to be denied a higher education and ---in their resistance --- created a set of institutions that would influence and shape the landscape of the country for centuries to come." (quoted from Ash é Cultural Arts Center newsletter, February 2018) Brief report on TAKE ONE                 My impressions of this documentary were prejudiced by (1) the advertising of the film, (2) my intimate knowledge of HBCUs from having been on the faculty of two of them fo
Read more