Some Humanists Should Not Go to Prison


SOME HUMANISTS SHOULD NOT GO TO PRISON

The title Why All Humanists Should Go to Prison   is ambiguous and ironic, a good match for the argument Alex Tipei made in The Chronicle of Higher Education, September 25, 2018.  Tipei is a liberal idealist who wishes to convince academics that "humanists can at once help reimagine the prison as a space of reform and reaffirm the humanities as a relevant mode of learning."  Her argument is provocative.  It reminds us that outmates can learn a great deal  from volunteering to teach inmates, can learn what the art of teaching might be in the panoptical confines of a jail or prison.  Nevertheless, Tipei fails to specify which humanists are fit to have face-to-face conversations with inmates.

 We know that a substantial number of humanists have difficulty in communicating their expertise to outmates in public settings. Ought we not have  second and third thoughts about how effectively they might communicate with incarcerated adult women and men,  how effectively they might teach  traumatized or nihilistic juveniles.  How many privileged humanists  have the compassion, juice, humility, and patience that is a prerequisite for intervening in the lives of the imprisoned?  It is reasonable to guess that few of them have these qualities, and they  ought never darken a prison door, unless they have committed acts that warrant their being inmates.  Tipei's vision is blurred by the thick smoke of good intentions.

Tipei fails to account for diversity in how prisons, especially for-profit prisons, are administered and for the fact that the American criminal justice system is predicated on desires to punish rather than desires  to rehabilitate. It is merely romantic (and truly safe) to associate volunteering to teach in a jail with the debatable "reimagining" that colors the humanities. Volunteering entails risks, including the risk of empathizing with inmates as one struggles to help them enhance their minds.

 Tipei lucked out in being able to teach "a master's level theory and methods course" in Indiana Women's Prison.  A more typical scenario entails teaching basics in writing, reading comprehension, science, mathematics, and social studies (the five sections of the HiSet Exam inmates have to pass in order to obtain high school equivalency) and reassuring  inmates that their minds must not be wasted.  Thus, there is a greater need to cultivate hope and mastery in the fundamentals of learning than to invest energy in academic theorizing.  Praxis matters.  There is a greater need to say to imprisoned students  "I refuse to allow you to fail yourself." There are exceptions, of course, especially in federal prisons that house many of our nation's intellectuals.

Tipei's pondering "questions concerning technology and pedagogy" is valuable at a time when fit humanists should apply the pedagogy of the oppressed to reduce the damage effected by American systems of criminal injustice. But I must emphasize that only fit humanists who can employ the habits of the heart with brutal honesty  and absence of bad faith should "go to prison."  The other humanists should remain in college and university classrooms and help entitlement-afflicted outmates to have epiphanies about their unspoken status as inmates of a different kind, about their reluctance to acknowledge that their nation is an existential prison, a space of panoptical confinement.

Jerry W. Ward, Jr.            September 25, 2018

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Christmas, Kwanzaa, 2018

Blog 12.19.2017 CHRISTMAS I have a reason for not being anxious to celebrate Advent and Christmas Day.   Sixty years ago, my father died on December 25.   Fifty-nine years ago, my favorite uncle died a few days before Christmas.   I do want other people to be happy, but I am most at peace when Christmas has gone with the snow, the sunshine or rain, the wind.   I still say "Merry Christmas."   The only genuine happiness I experience, however, is listening to Handel's "The Messiah" and a few songs I've treasured since childhood,   attending Midnight Mass, having home-made fruitcake   after Mass, and eating a special meal with relatives on the excessively commercialized holiday. KWANZAA Umoja ---Decide with whom you should seek unity. Kujichagulia --Expand the terms of engagement for 2018. Ujima ---Cooperate on a project with people you can trust. Ujamaa --Be frugal.   Shop selectively. Nia ---Remember ou...
Read more

implacable violence, part one

Implacable Violence, Part One The death of Senator John McCain quickens our   interest in how to deal with contemporary   narratives of life history.   McCain's touchstone story pertains to American conservative values, the consequences of trauma,   military and public service, violence, and   a sense of honor.   Barack Obama's differently remarkable narratives direct attention to the absence of military service, class and caste violence, the audacity of hope, centralist values, and diversity in the history of "race."   Narratives about McCain and Obama stand in noteworthy contrast to future narratives about Donald Trump, stories that may place ego in the foreground as they unfold tales of sexism, constipated values,     inadvertent racism, the violence of capitalism, sleight of mouth, and avoidance of military service.   Ego, self-fashioning, and boldness are apparent in the three sets of narrative, but excess lynches the Trump set...
Read more

DuBois and Black Reconstruction

  PROPAGATION OF HISTORY AND FAITH   DuBois, W. E. B.   Black Reconstruction in America 1860-1880 . (1935; New York: The Free Press, 1998).   Dr. DuBois knew what was problematic about his revisionist history in Black Reconstruction .   He made his intentions clear in his note "To The Reader" (December 1934).   His ideal audience consisted of people who believed a black person in America "and in general is an average and ordinary human being, who under given environment develops like other human beings…"   DuBois was not trying to convince those who regarded " the Negro as a distinctly inferior creation, who can never successfully take part in modern civilization…"   Indeed, the Negro, in my mind at least, is the chief architect of civilization.   Is it only a matter of accident that Carter G. Woodson's The Mis-Education of the Negro was published   two years before Black Reconstruction ?   No.   It wasn't an accide...
Read more